WHY YOUR MARITAL AGREEMENT SHOULD BE SHOWN TO YOUR ESTATE PLANNING ATTORNEY
July 16, 2020
Why Your Marital Agreement Should Be Shown to Your Estate Planner
It is not uncommon for couples to enter into marital agreements stating what property is separately owned by each spouse and the property rights each spouse will have in the event of separation, divorce, or death. They are most common when one or both of the spouses is wealthy, owns a family business, or expects a large inheritance, as well as when one or both spouses marries for a second time. Because these agreements can change or limit a surviving spouse’s right to inherit, play certain roles in their deceased spouse’s estate plan, or take advantage of certain tax benefits, they can have a substantial effect on an estate plan.
If you and your spouse have a marital agreement, it is crucial for you to provide a copy of it to your estate planning attorney to avoid conflicts between provisions in your estate planning and the marital agreement. If the documents conflict, a probate court will have to determine which of the documents will take precedence over the other—meaning there will likely be expensive litigation.
What Is a Marital Agreement?
There are two common types of marital agreements:
Prenuptial agreement. A prenuptial agreement is entered into by two people before they get married. Although state law varies, these agreements must typically meet several requirements to be valid and enforceable: (1) the agreement must be in writing and signed by both parties; (2) each prospective spouse must voluntarily agree to the terms of the agreement; (3) both parties must make full and accurate disclosures beforehand; (4) each spouse must have an opportunity to consult their own lawyer; and (5) the agreement must not be unconscionable, i.e., very unfair to either party.
Postnuptial agreement. A postnuptial agreement is entered into after the marriage has occurred. The rules for enforceability are similar to those noted above regarding prenuptial agreements. Although in the past, postnuptial agreements were regarded less favorably than prenuptial agreements because of the perception that there was more potential for unfairness to one of the spouses, they are now frequently upheld in court.
A Marital Agreement Can Alter a Surviving Spouse’s Rights Under State Law
In the absence of a marital agreement, a surviving spouse typically has the right to inherit a certain amount of the deceased spouse’s accounts and property under state law. The way that this occurs typically depends upon whether the state is a common law state or a community property state.
Elective share. Common law states typically have laws providing a surviving spouse with the option to receive an “elective share” of a deceased spouse’s estate, even if there are provisions in his or her will disinheriting or making only an extremely small gift to the spouse. The surviving spouse can elect to take the share provided by statute (often a third or a half of the deceased spouse’s estate—the same amount he or she could have inherited under state law if there had been no will) or to accept the terms of the will. In some states, the surviving spouse is not limited to what he or she would have received if there had been no will and is also permitted to elect against certain money or property not required to go through the probate process, such as money or property held in a revocable living trust. If the surviving spouse takes the elective share, he or she may be inheriting more than the deceased spouse intended—and other beneficiaries may inherit less.
Community property. In a community property state, like California, all the property resulting from the fruits of the labor of either spouse during the marriage is considered to belong to the marital unit and is deemed to be shared equally. Property acquired during the marriage is typically presumed to be community property (1) in the absence of evidence that the property was brought to the marriage by one spouse, (2) if it was a gift or inheritance to one spouse, (3) if it was separate property before a move into a community property state, or (4) if there is an agreement to the contrary.
A marital agreement can change these statutory rights. Although limiting a spouse’s inheritance rights may seem heartless at first glance, it is not uncommon, particularly in a second marriage where one or both spouses have children from a first marriage and each one came into the marriage financially secure. In that situation, the children are often the main beneficiaries of their parent’s will or trust, as parents commonly want their estate to primarily benefit their own family rather than the family of a new spouse. There also are many other factual situations in which spouses may find it beneficial to enter into a marital agreement altering these statutory rights. If the intention is for the surviving spouse not to receive this elective share or unaltered community property rights, a valid marital agreement should be put into place stating how the couple has agreed the property should be treated at death.
A Marital Agreement Can Clarify Whether a Surviving Spouse Will Benefit from a Portability Election
Federal tax law allows a surviving spouse to utilize any unused portion of their deceased spouse’s lifetime gift and estate tax exemption ($11.58 million for individuals for 2020) in addition to his or her own exemption amount. However, for portability to be available to the surviving spouse, a portability election must be made by filing an estate tax return for the deceased spouse even if the estate is not large enough to necessitate it. If the surviving spouse is very wealthy, the deceased spouse’s unused exemption amount, added to the surviving spouse’s exemption amount, could result in substantial tax savings benefiting the surviving spouse’s beneficiaries.
Consequently, particularly in the case of a second marriage, when one or both spouses have children who may act as their executor or trustee, the marital agreement should specifically address this issue. If the spouse who dies first wishes for the surviving spouse to be able to benefit from a portability election, this should be clearly stated in the marital agreement. If not, it should be waived in the marital agreement. For couples who have a marital agreement that was put in place before 2010, the year when the law allowing portability was enacted, it is wise to review it and make any amendments needed to specifically address portability.
The marital agreement may be referenced in the predeceasing spouse’s will or trust, which can explicitly instruct the executor or trustee to follow its terms and can clearly allocate the burden of paying for the preparing and filing the estate tax return. The burden is often placed on the surviving spouse, that is, the party that stands to benefit from the portability election. In addition, the martial agreement could set forth any benefits that will flow to other family members to compensate for the benefit associated with portability. If this issue is addressed in advance, substantial conflict between surviving family members may be avoided.
We Can Help Eliminate Uncertainty
Families can be more complex these days than they often were in the past. A marital agreement can be an important element of a comprehensive estate plan designed for your unique circumstances. If you have a marital agreement, we can help ensure that the rights and goals you and your spouse have established are also reflected in your estate planning documents, eliminating any uncertainty about your wishes. Give us a call today to set up an appointment. We are happy to meet with you online or by phone if you prefer.